HS2: Nash roars

nash

NASH Ali let loose on Sir David Higgins, the HS2 boss, last week, channeling a bit of Oscar Wilde (price of everything, value of nothing) and Martin Luther King (judged on the content of their character) to make his stand for people living on the Regent’s Park estate. Sir David had suggested that by knocking down people’s homes behind Euston for the high speed rail scheme, the project would actually be healing ‘deprivation’. That in some way, he suggested, the best way to help the neighbourhood was to re-locate people from homes they’ve lived in for a generation and allow ‘big players’ to re-develop the land. Those big players, of course, are unlikely to be building new social housing, if the example of the King’s Cross regeneration site a few minutes down the road is any yardstick.

Nash’s decision to charge his open letter with references to Sir David being a “white Australian”, pitched against the “blot” of Drummond Street curry houses, was a bit uncomfortable. Politicians normally step carefully around such elements. The power of his letter may also have been sapped by the curious addendum of congratulating the man he had just bucketed with anger for his work on the Olympics.

But this was the strongest terms in which Nash has spoken out against HS2, publicly at least. It made some of those who read its content wonder why he had not been so bold before, especially during his two year tenure as council leader. Somewhere down the line, he had been advised that he had to restrict his opposition to the HS2 scheme because his family lived in one of the snatched blocks, as if a conflict of interest made his views wholly invalid. There was a worried slowness to produce a powerful complaint and in the void, he was challenged for the council leadership by Sarah Hayward. He stepped down. She took over – and her time in charge has been stamped, more than anything, by her angry and very public protestations against HS2. In truth, the HS2 debate had grown so big, the issue so perilous, that the petty accusation that any opposition from Nash would’ve simply been an interest in helping his own had been overtaken by the need to ‘save Camden’.

Did he roar too late? If he retains any bitterness, it is not noticeable. While internal Labour Party divisions rarely heal perfectly, he does not set out each week to undermine Sarah in his role within her cabinet. Recently, he seems relaxed and pragmatic, proud still of being in charge when Labour won the council back in 2010 after four years of punishment.

And the point he makes to Sir David is strong. While there were celebrations that the juggernaut Camden Link work had been abandoned earlier this month and that ten years of scary upheaval in Camden Town would not now go ahead, the issue of Euston and the Regent’s Park provides a sobering balance. HS2 now want Euston to be maxed out, to lever in new finance for the £50 billion scheme as a whole. But in presenting his vision, Sir David was wrong to cast the entrenched community around Regent’s Park and Drummond Street as being similar to Stratford which genuinely benefited from the Olympic transformation. Property values. for starters, are contrasting from the starting point they were at in Stratford to what they already are in Euston. Sir David has still not explained how the deprived, a word which was felt as patronising by many who live in the area, will be best helped by having their streets swapped for a forest of tower blocks for familiar multinationals to play in.

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

3 Comments on HS2: Nash roars

  1. Das Kapital // March 31, 2014 at 5:04 pm // Reply

    I remember once e-mailing Cllr Ali regarding a constituent who was going through a crisis, I asked him to contact me as a matter of urgency, but no response was ever received!

    Yes, why has it taken so long for this gentleman to come out of the woodwork so to speak……………

    Daz

    Like

    • Das Kapital // March 31, 2014 at 10:41 pm // Reply

      Jesus, I was stupid and more than a bit slow on this occasion!

      I forgot, aren’t we close to a local election in May!

      Daz

      Like

  2. Darren May // April 1, 2014 at 6:43 pm // Reply

    I will never forget the difference that Nash has made to my life and the life of thousands of people in Camden. I was part of Camden United and it helped to unite the Bangladeshi community and the white community during a time of heavy racism in the late eighties and nineties. The murder of Richard Everitt stirred up the racial hatred against the Bangladeshi community. Some of my friends and I were talking in the Dublin Castle recently with Henry, the owner, about the difference Nash has made to Camden. If it wasn’t for Nash then Camden wouldn’t be under Labour now. The large Muslim community in Camden voted for Labour becaus it had Nash, a Muslim and Bangladeshi Leader. It’s easy for Sarah Hayward to step in after Nash has done all the hardwork.

    In my opinion and that of thousands of people in Camden, Nash is a real hero and should be knighted for his work.

    In terms of HS2, we all know Nash’s family lives in Silverdale and I spoke to him about it once and he told me about the QC advice he got, when he was Leader, cautioning him against speaking out about HS2 because of his conflict of interest.

    Nash is a great Cabinet Member for Young People and the Labour Party in Camden must not forget what Nash has done for them or it will be their loss!!!

    Like

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: